As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you make a purchase through links on this site.As an eBay Partner, we may earn from purchases via our links.

Guides · Buying Guide

Tetairoa McMillan Rookie Cards: Which to Buy and What They're Worth

From a PSA 10 White Disco Prizm listed at $140 to a Prizm Silver rookie listed at $4.74, here's what the 2025 Offensive Rookie of the Year's rookie cards cost today, and which one to buy for your budget.

What is Tetairoa McMillan's rookie card?

Tetairoa McMillan's rookie cards are from 2025 Panini sets, the year the Carolina Panthers took him eighth overall out of Arizona. He went on to win the 2025 AP Offensive Rookie of the Year award. Like most modern rookies, each of his main cards comes in many color versions called parallels, some numbered to a small print run, and those decide most of the price.

  • 2025 Prizm #311: his flagship rookie. The shiny Silver version is the one most collectors mean, and colors like White Disco and Lazer sit above it.
  • 2025 Prizm #401: a rookie image variation, a harder-to-find version of the Prizm card with a different photo.
  • 2025 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #209: the chrome version of the classic Rated Rookie design, with Holo, Blue Hyper, Blue Scope and numbered colors such as Neon Yellow (numbered to 15).
  • 2025 Prizm Draft Picks #8: a card showing him in college colors. It is printed in his rookie year, and many collectors treat it as a lower-cost alternative to the Panthers rookies.

The headline card: 2025 Prizm Silver #311

The Prizm Silver is the standard rookie card for any modern NFL star, and McMillan's is no exception. It is also cheap right now in ungraded form: our nightly sales check recorded raw copies selling at auction for between $0.99 and $5.50 from October 16 to November 10, 2026. Graded copies in top condition cost much more, so read whether a listing is raw or slabbed.

The 2025 Prizm Silver #311, the card most collectors mean by his rookie. #3 on our Tetairoa McMillan list

On November 15, 2026, the cheapest raw copy our site matched on eBay was listed at $4.74.

What's realistic at different budgets

Prices below are the lowest live eBay listings our site matched on November 15, 2026. They change daily, and the grade decides most of the price.

  • Under $50: Prizm Draft Picks Silver (#8) raw from $1.25, Optic Rated Rookie Holo (#209) raw from $2.25, Prizm Lazer (#311) raw from $2.49, Prizm Silver (#311) raw from $4.74, the Prizm image variation Silver (#401) raw from $5.
  • $50 to $250: graded PSA 10 copies, such as the Prizm Draft Picks Silver at $79.95, the Optic Blue Hyper at $90, the Prizm Lazer at $109.99 and the Prizm White Disco at $140.
  • $250 and up: the low-numbered colors. His Optic Rated Rookie Neon Yellow, numbered to 15, had no copy listed on November 15. Sports Illustrated reported a 2025 Absolute Kaboom! Gold numbered to 10 selling for $8,697 on November 27, 2025, and a Donruss Gold Downtown numbered to 10 in PSA 10 selling for $8,650 on November 20, 2025.
  1. 2025 Panini Prizm

    White Disco

    Card #311

    The White Disco Prizm parallel of his rookie, with a dotted, mirror-ball pattern.

    last sold $28 eBay, 3 sales · Oct 2026
    Recent sales 3 on eBay in 90 days · $1.60–$42
    $28 · Raw · Oct 12$1.60 · Raw · Oct 20$42 · Raw · Oct 22
    See all 3 sales
    DateGradeSold for
    Oct 22Raw$42
    Oct 20Raw$1.60
    Oct 12Raw$28
    Search on eBay →
The White Disco Prizm, a step up from the Silver for a few dollars raw. #4 on our Tetairoa McMillan list
Our verdictGreat value

Buy the Prizm Silver #311, raw or graded

It is his flagship rookie and sold for $5.50 or less raw at auction from October 16 to November 10, 2026. If you want a card that holds its condition, a graded copy of the same card costs more but is still within a normal budget.

About: 2025 Panini Prizm Silver #311 · #3 on our Tetairoa McMillan list

Graded vs. raw

For McMillan's base rookies, grading is most of the price. The Prizm Draft Picks Silver was listed raw from $1.25 on November 15, 2026, while a PSA 10 copy was listed at $79.95 and a PSA 9 at $46. The Prizm Lazer showed the same gap: $2.49 raw against $109.99 in PSA 10.

That gap only matters for a perfect 10. If you are buying the card to enjoy, a clean raw copy costs a few dollars. If you are buying it as a collectible you hope holds value, pay for a PSA 10 rather than grading a raw card yourself, since many raw cards do not come back a 10.

  1. 2025 Panini Prizm Draft Picks

    Silver

    Card #8

    The Silver Prizm of his Draft Picks card, showing him at Arizona.

    last seen $46 on eBay
    Search on eBay →
The Prizm Draft Picks Silver #8, one of his cheapest cards raw. #8 on our Tetairoa McMillan list

How to avoid a wrong or fake listing

  1. Match the card number: Prizm is #311 (#401 for the image variation), Donruss Optic Rated Rookie is #209 and Prizm Draft Picks is #8.
  2. Check the year: his Panthers rookies are 2025. A card showing him at Arizona is a Draft Picks or college card, not a Panthers rookie.
  3. For a numbered color, look for the serial number stamped on the card, such as 07/15, and make sure the color matches the photo.
  4. Compare sold prices, not asking prices. A high ask on eBay is a weak signal of value.
Good to know

Prizm and Optic colors can look alike in photos. If a listing's title and photo disagree, ask the seller for a clearer picture before you buy.

  1. 2025 Panini Donruss Optic

    Holo · Rated Rookie

    Card #209

    The Holo parallel of his Optic Rated Rookie, the shiny step up from the base card.

    last seen $25 on eBay
    Search on eBay →
The Donruss Optic Rated Rookie Holo #209. #7 on our Tetairoa McMillan list

Quick answers

What is Tetairoa McMillan's rookie card?
His main rookie card is the 2025 Prizm #311, especially the Silver version. His 2025 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #209 and 2025 Prizm Draft Picks #8 are also rookie-year cards.
What is Tetairoa McMillan's most valuable rookie card?
His low-numbered colors are the most valuable. Sports Illustrated reported a 2025 Absolute Kaboom! Gold numbered to 10 selling for $8,697 on November 27, 2025.
How much is a Tetairoa McMillan rookie card worth?
A raw Prizm Silver #311 sold for between $0.99 and $5.50 at auction from October 16 to November 10, 2026. Graded PSA 10 copies of his base rookies were listed from about $80 to $140 on November 15, 2026.
Are Tetairoa McMillan cards a good investment?
Sports cards are collectibles, not guaranteed investments. Values move with on-field performance and hobby demand, and can fall as fast as they rise. This guide is for research, not financial advice.

Where this comes from

Facts
2025 AP Offensive Rookie of the Year award
Facts
Eighth overall pick in the 2025 draft; award announced Feb. 5, 2026
Facts
Dated sales: Absolute Kaboom! Gold /10 ($8,697, Nov 27, 2025) and Donruss Gold Downtown /10 PSA 10 ($8,650, Nov 20, 2025)
Facts
Donruss Optic Rated Rookie card number #209

Prices shown come from eBay listings and refresh daily, so they may be up to a day old. Sports cards are collectibles, not investments — this guide is for research and enjoyment, not financial advice.