John Elway Card Prices
As of Oct 26, 2026, we pulled 74 John Elway card listings from eBay. Their Buy It Now prices run from $0.99 to $352, and half are under $2.53. 1 are graded (PSA, BGS, SGC or CGC).
Every John Elway card currently listed on eBay, in one place — not ranked, not verified card-by-card like our most popular cards list, just real live inventory for browsing the full breadth of what’s out there. Filter by price, graded cards, autographs or auctions ending soon.
74 listings·as of Oct 26, 2026
2026
4 cards
2025
5 cards
John Elway 2025 Topps Hall Of Chrome Autographs Orange Denver Broncos /25 READ$140.00
2025 Panini NT - Century Materials John Elway #CM-JEY Holo Silver 1/25 🔥$50.00
2025 Topps Cosmic Chrome Football John Elway Lightyears SSP Broncos #LY-1$199.99
2025 Donruss Optic #171 John Elway Holo$1.99
2025 Donruss Football - #255 John Elway$1.37
2024
1 card
2023
2 cards
2021
1 card
2020
1 card
2016
2 cards
2015
3 cards
2014
2 cards
2013
4 cards
2008
1 card
2002
1 card
2001
1 card
1999
2 cards
1998
4 cards
1997
6 cards
John Elway Broncos HOF 1997 Pacific Revolution #42 (F1)$3.99
John Elway ETCHED SILVER FOIL CARD Denver Broncos 1997 Metal Universe$31.49
John Elway #98 1997 SkyBox Premium Denver Broncos NFL Reebok Football Card$1.19
1997 Topps ~ John Elway ~ 200 ~ Broncos$0.99
1997 Topps #HO-11 John Elway High Octane$3.95
1997 Skybox Marvel Metal Universe John Elway #8 Denver Broncos NFL Football$113.13
1996
2 cards
1995
4 cards
1994
5 cards
1993
1 card
1992
1 card
1991
2 cards
1990
2 cards
1989
1 card
1988
2 cards
1986
1 card
1985
1 card
1984
2 cards
Other
10 cards
John Elway STANFORD### Buy 5 Get 1 Free ## Or 30% Off 12 Diddy-Original-Customs$4.99
John Elway Trophy Collection Foil Card Broncos Hall Of Fame$31.49
John Elway Extreme Team Gold Foil Card Broncos Hall Of Fame$44.99
John Elway Fleet Farm Super Bowl Trophy Foil Card Broncos Hall Of Fame SP$33.74
John Elway Double Potrait Holo Foil Card Denver Broncos Hall Of Fame Legend$31.49
Custom Lego Football Card - John Elway$7.99
John Elway Gold Refractorcard Panini Broncos Mint$20.99
John Elway Football Cards You Pick BRONCOS HOF Revised 9/13$1.39
John Elway Denver Broncos 🏈METAL Baseball Card⚾ Oneonta Tigers / Yankees$6.99
John Elway Gold Confetti Foil Card Broncos Hall Of Fame$33.74
Auctions ending soon
soonest firstNo auctions from our latest snapshot are still running, but see every John Elway auction ending soon on eBay
Frequently asked
How much are John Elway cards worth?
It depends on the card. In our latest pull of John Elway listings on eBay, Buy It Now prices run from $0.99 to $352, and half are under $2.53. Rookie cards, low numbered parallels and high grades (like PSA 10) sit at the top. Asking prices aren't sale prices, so check recent sold listings before you buy.
Is this the same as your John Elway most popular cards list?
No. This page shows every current eBay listing for John Elway, unranked and unverified. Our most popular list is a curated top 10, with each card's identity and price checked individually.
Are these listings verified?
No — this is raw eBay inventory filtered only by player name, not checked card-by-card. Always confirm the year, set, and condition on the actual listing before buying.
How often does this page update?
Listings come from a snapshot of eBay taken for our site (the date is at the top of the page), so prices and availability can lag real-time eBay — always check the listing itself.
Why show unverified listings at all?
Seeing everything currently for sale — cheap base cards and expensive rarities side by side — is useful for browsing the full breadth of John Elway's cards, not just the priciest ones.