Browse Every Peyton Manning Card
Every Peyton Manning card currently listed on eBay, in one place — not ranked, not verified card-by-card like our grail list, just real live inventory for browsing the full breadth of what’s out there.
77 listings·as of Sep 17, 2026
2026
1 card
2025
3 cards
2024
1 card
2023
1 card
2022
2 cards
2021
2 cards
2020
3 cards
2016
1 card
2015
2 cards
2014
2 cards
2013
3 cards
2012
1 card
2011
1 card
2009
2 cards
2008
3 cards
2007
3 cards
2005
1 card
2003
2 cards
2002
3 cards
2001
4 cards
2000
4 cards
1999
10 cards
Topps Stadium Club 1999 Peyton Manning 3x3 Luminous Die-Cut #T4A Colts$15.00
1999 Topps All Matrix #AM19 Peyton Manning - FB$8.00
1999 Topps Gold Label #61 Peyton Manning Black$7.49
1999 Upper Deck HoloGrFX #N4 Peyton Manning NFL 24/7$2.99
Donruss 1999 Donruss Elite Peyton Manning Colts #8 Serial Numbered /2500$20.00
Peyton Manning 1999 Topps Stars 3 Star #23 Colts$1.50
Peyton Manning cards (1999-2004) Colts - You Choose$0.99
1999 Donruss Preferred QBC - Chain Reaction Peyton Manning #10B /5000$20.00
1999 Upper Deck MVP - Souvenirs Peyton Manning #PM-S (MEM)$64.99
1999 Topps Stadium Chrome Eyes of the Game Peyton Manning Acetate #SCCE25 N/M-MT$15.99
1998
16 cards
1998 Topps Season Opener - Draft Picks #1 Peyton Manning RC ROOKIE EX-NM$25.00
1998 Upper Deck Black Diamond Rookie Edition Peyton Manning #91 (RC)$18.00
🔥1998 Fleer Metal Universe Peyton Manning Rookie RC Card #189 TN Volunteers🔥$35.00
MINT ROOKIE 1998 Collector's Edge Peyton Manning Peyton Manning (Holding jersey)$9.95
1998 Topps Gold Label #20 Peyton Manning RC ROOKIE Very Sharp Card NM-MT$30.00
1998 Collector's Edge Odyssey #172 Peyton Manning$5.95
1998 Collector's Edge Rookie Record Setters #135 Peyton Manning RC Auto Colts$249.99
1998 Bowman’s Best Peyton Manning Best Performers RC #BP1 Indianapolis Colts$17.99
Topps 1998 Topps Peyton Manning #360 Draft Picks Indianapolis Colts RC$29.99
1998 Skybox thunder StarBurst #6 Peyton Manning RC ROOKIE Very Sharp Card EX+$17.00
1998 - Score Artist's Proof - Peyton Manning - PP123 - PSA 8 Nm-mt - Rookie$219.99
1998 Upper Deck UD Choice - Rookie Class Peyton Manning #193 (RC)$26.76
1998 Collector’s Edge 1st Place — GOLD — Peyton Manning — ROOKIE — PSA 8$95.00
1998 Topps Autographs Peyton Manning RC Bronze #A10B BGS 8.5 / 10 PERFECT auto🔥$3,000.00
1998 Bowman Chrome #BCP1 Peyton Manning PREVIEW RC ROOKIE Very Sharp Card$30.00
PEYTON MANNING Colts 1998 Draft Pick Throwback FEEL the GAME Card - GEM-MINT 10$18.95
1989
1 card
Other
5 cards
🏈 Peyton Manning “Vols” Sticker 🏈$6.00
Leaf Sports Heroes Peyton Manning/Ryan Leaf Pre-Production Proof 1/1 Card$65.00
Playoff Great American Heroes Peyton Manning Colts NFL GAH-13 /2500$20.00
Peyton Manning Custom Art Trading Card – Fan Made Collectible$5.00
Leaf Rookies & Stars Statistical Standouts Peyton Manning /250 #SS-6$45.00
Frequently asked
- Is this the same as your Peyton Manning grail list?
- No. This page shows every current eBay listing for Peyton Manning, unranked and unverified. Our grail list is a curated top 10, with each card's identity and price checked individually.
- Are these listings verified?
- No — this is raw eBay inventory filtered only by player name, not checked card-by-card. Always confirm the year, set, and condition on the actual listing before buying.
- How often does this page update?
- Listings refresh regularly as part of our site build, so prices and availability can lag real-time eBay by a day or two.
- Why show unverified listings at all?
- Seeing everything currently for sale — cheap base cards and expensive grails side by side — is useful for browsing the full breadth of Peyton Manning's cards, not just the priciest ones.