NFL teams · 6 players
Buffalo Bills Cards for Sale
The Bills cards fans hunt for, from Josh Allen, James Cook, D.J. Moore, Jim Kelly and more. Each player’s cards for sale on eBay right now, today’s stars first, then the legends.
Updated Nov 15, 2026
James Cook
2022 Panini Mosaic - NFL Debut James Cook #285 Mosaic Peacock Prizm (RC)Last seen $40.00
2024 Score - James Cook #29 Signatures (AU)Last seen $24.99
James Cook 2022 Donruss Optic #RHR-6 Red Rookies Purple Stars PSA 10Last seen $150.00
2022 Panini Obsidian Electric Etch Orange James Cook #109 RC /75Last seen $27.99
D.J. Moore
D.J. Moore 2018 Select Auto Patch RC Green #5/5 PSA 8 Panthers/BillsLast seen $399.99
Topps 2026 Holiday DJ Moore Buffalo Bills #111 Auto Topps Certified 19/25Last seen $80.00
D.J. Moore Rookie 2018 Prizm Orange Die Cut #d/249 Near Mint/Mint Buffalo BillsLast seen $25.46
2024 Panini Prizm - D.J. Moore #48 Green Shimmer Prizm 4/5 BillsLast seen $39.99
Jim Kelly
Jim Kelly Buffalo Bills Immortalized Auto Patch /25 (check description)Last seen $50.00
2025 Resurgence #TRI-JK Jim Kelly Thermal Red Auto Red Power Surge Refractor 5/5Last seen $100.00
2024 Topps Chrome Jim Kelly Gold Legends Refractor Auto /50 #CLA-JKLast seen $38.99
Jim Kelly 2008 Upper Deck SP Authentic Numbers Jersey Patch Auto SP 4/15 BillsLast seen $499.99
Thurman Thomas
2018 Impeccable Thurman Thomas Indelible Ink On Card Autograph #38/49Last seen $50.00
2024 Panini National Treasures Thurman Thomas Treasures of the Hall #TOH-TTS /25Last seen $20.00
2021 Score Thurman Thomas First Down #/10 SN HOF #26 Buffalo BillsLast seen $24.99
1989 Score THURMAN THOMAS #211 PSA 9 NFL HOF Set Registry Bills Rookie RCLast seen $29.95
Bruce Smith
Bruce Smith 2024 Panini HALL OF FAME /50 ON CARD AUTO🔥Last seen $90.00
2018 Panini Limited Bruce Smith Emerald Ring of Honor /3 Auto #ROH-BS BillsLast seen $95.00
2024 topps midnight football bruce smith auto # /75 A-6Last seen $22.00
Playoff 1998 Playoff Prestige Bruce Smith #116 Buffalo Bills Gold /25 2611194Last seen $59.95
More Bills cards on eBay
Topps 2026 Flagship Josh Allen Buffalo Bills #22 Holo Foil Parallel GradedLast seen $20.00
Panini 2025 Score Josh Allen Buffalo Bills #159 Trick or Treat /99 ParallelLast seen $140.00
Leaf Premium Josh Allen Buffalo Bills #X Autograph Leaf Auth Football CardLast seen $300.00
2025 Panini Buffalo Bills Farewell Season Steve Tasker SS-1 Significant AutoLast seen $29.99
Topps 2026 Inception Josh Allen Buffalo Bills Football Base #16Last seen $65.00
Josh Allen SILVER FOIL CARD Buffalo Bills MVPLast seen $31.49
Josh Allen 2026 Topps Pressure Cookers PC-7 Gold 47/50 BillsLast seen $60.00
2025 Topps Chrome Josh Allen Geometric Refractor SSP Est Print Run 65 #34 BillsLast seen $55.00
💎 2025 Panini Buffalo Bills Highmark Farewell Season Ltd Edition 36 Card Set 💎Last seen $20.00
2026 Topps Flagship James Cook Touchdown Machines Gold /50 #TM-4 Buffalo BillsLast seen $45.00
2025 Topps Resurgence Josh Allen Buffalo Bills Card #10Last seen $27.99
2019 Panini Certified Fabric of the Game Josh Allen Bills FG-JA /299 PLAYER WORNLast seen $60.00



