As an eBay Partner, we may be compensated if you make a purchase through links on this site.As an eBay Partner, we may earn from purchases via our links.

Enthusiast tier · $100–$500

Enthusiast Tier: The Best Sports Cards from $100 to $500

The sweet spot for a real collection: graded rookies, numbered parallels and autographs of stars, priced from $100 to just under $500. The list starts with the most valuable card in the range.

Updated Nov 14, 2026

Top 50, most valuable first

All prices →

We found 765 cards in this price range today. These are the 50 most valuable, with no more than 2 per player.

  1. 2021 Panini Donruss Optic

    Chuba Hubbard

    Rookie Patch Autographs

    /25
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  2. 2016 Panini Contenders

    Dak Prescott

    Rookie Ticket Autographs

    SSP
    from $499.99 on eBay
  3. 2025 Topps Chrome

    Jeremiah Fears

    Orange Geometric Refractor

    /25
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  4. 2014 Topps Premier League Stickers (Merlin)

    Harry Kane

    from $499.99 on eBay
  5. 2022 Bowman Chrome

    Jackson Merrill

    Purple Refractor · Prospect Autographs

    /250
    from $499.99 on eBay
  6. 2025 Bowman Chrome

    JJ Wetherholt

    Green Refractor · Chrome Prospect Autographs

    /99
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  7. 2013 Panini Spectra

    Mike Ditka

    50th Anniversary Hall of Fame Signatures

    /50
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  8. 2023 Panini Immaculate Collection

    Scoot Henderson

    Rookie Patch Autographs

    /99
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  9. 2020 Panini Contenders

    Justin Jefferson

    Rookie Ticket Autographs

    from $499.99 on eBay
  10. 2024 Bowman University Chrome

    Dylan Harper

    Prospect Autographs

    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  11. 2023 Topps Chrome Update

    Gunnar Henderson

    Rookie Autographs

    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  12. 2021 Panini Prizm WNBA

    Jackie Young

    Gold

    /10
    from $499.99 on eBay
  13. 2025 Topps Chrome Formula 1

    Liam Lawson

    Orange Raywave Auto

    /25
    from $499.99 on eBay
  14. 2019 Panini Donruss WNBA

    Kelsey Mitchell

    Optic

    from $499.99 on eBay
  15. 2010 Topps Chrome

    Buster Posey

    Green Refractor · Wrapper Redemption

    /599
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  16. 2018 Bowman Chrome

    Shohei Ohtani

    from $499.99 on eBay
  17. 2025 Topps Chrome

    Tre Johnson

    Orange RayWave

    /25
    last seen $499.99 on eBay
  18. 2014 Bowman

    Mookie Betts

    Rookie Autographs

    from $499.99 on eBay
  19. 2024 Panini Prizm WNBA

    Caitlin Clark

    Red

    /299
    from $499.99 on eBay
  20. 2020 Topps Merlin Chrome UEFA

    Jamal Musiala

    Orange

    /25
    from $499.95 on eBay
  21. 2021 Topps Chrome Formula 1

    Mick Schumacher

    Red Refractor

    /5
    last seen $499.95 on eBay
  22. 2025 Bowman Chrome

    Jesús Made

    Orange Refractor · Chrome Prospect Autographs

    /25
    from $499.88 on eBay
  23. 2025 Topps Chrome

    Tre Johnson

    Orange Geometric

    /25
    last seen $499 on eBay
  24. 2020 Panini Prizm

    Jalen Hurts

    Silver

    from $499 on eBay
  25. 1980 Panini F1 Grand Prix

    Alain Prost

    last sold $499 PSA 9 · Sports Card Investor · Jul 2024last seen $260.95 on eBay
  26. 2024 Panini Prizm Premier League

    Cole Palmer

    Gold

    /10
    from $499 on eBay
  27. 2024 Topps Chrome

    Wyatt Langford

    Orange · Rookie Autographs

    /25
    from $499 on eBay
  28. 2011 Bowman Platinum

    Bryce Harper

    Prospect Autographs

    last seen $499 on eBay
  29. 2025 Topps Chrome Cactus Jack

    Carter Bryant

    Red Refractor

    /5
    last seen $499 on eBay
  30. 2018 Bowman Chrome

    Yordan Alvarez

    Prospect Autographs

    from $498.97 on eBay
  31. 2008 Panini Ekstraklasa

    Robert Lewandowski

    Rookie

    last seen $495.47 on eBay
  32. 2020 Panini Prizm

    Tyrese Haliburton

    Gold

    /10
    last seen $495 on eBay
  33. 2024 Bowman Chrome

    Wyatt Langford

    Orange · Chrome Prospect Autographs

    /25
    last seen $495 on eBay
  34. 1998 Fleer Tradition

    Peyton Manning

    last seen $495 on eBay
  35. 2020 Topps Chrome UEFA Champions League

    Jamal Musiala

    Orange Bubbles Refractor

    last seen $489.99 on eBay
  36. 2025 Bowman University Chrome

    Fernando Mendoza

    Autographs

    from $489 on eBay
  37. 2025 Bowman Chrome

    Cameron Boozer

    Blue · Chrome Prospect Autographs

    /150
    last sold $488.90 eBay auction · Oct 2026last seen $999 on eBay
  38. 1996 Skybox E-X2000

    Chris Mullin

    Credentials

    /499
    last seen $488.88 on eBay
  39. 2024 Topps Chrome

    Elly De La Cruz

    Rookie Autographs

    last seen $485 on eBay
  40. 1980 Topps Baseball

    Nolan Ryan

    last seen $479.95 on eBay
  41. 2023 Topps Chrome McDonald's All-American

    JuJu Watkins

    Refractor · Chrome Autographs

    from $477 on eBay
  42. 2020 Panini Prizm WNBA

    A'ja Wilson

    Orange

    /65
    from $475 on eBay
  43. 2024 Topps Chrome Update

    Paul Skenes

    Rookie Autographs

    from $475 on eBay
  44. 1996 Topps Chrome

    Hakeem Olajuwon

    Refractor

    last seen $475 on eBay
  45. 2025 Topps Chrome Update

    Dylan Harper

    last seen $475 on eBay
  46. 2022 Panini Select La Liga

    Robert Lewandowski

    Stained Glass

    from $460 on eBay
  47. 2000 Bowman Chrome

    Brian Urlacher

    Refractor

    last sold $455 BGS 9 · eBay auction · Oct 2026from $860 on eBay

Frequently asked

How are these cards ranked?

By value, highest first. When we have a recent real sale for the card that matches the copy for sale, we use that sale price; otherwise we use the lowest current asking price on eBay. Obvious junk listings (a few dollars) are left out.

What counts as $100–$500?

Cards valued from $100 up to (but not including) $500. A card at exactly $500 moves up to the Collector tier.

Why is a player listed twice?

We allow up to 2 cards per player on this page, so a star with two great cards in this price range can show both without one player taking over the list.