NFL teams · 7 players
Indianapolis Colts Cards for Sale
The Colts cards fans hunt for, from Jonathan Taylor, Anthony Richardson, Peyton Manning, Andrew Luck and more. Each player’s cards for sale on eBay right now, today’s stars first, then the legends.
Updated Oct 4, 2026
Andrew Luck
Topps 2012 Topps Platinum Andrew Luck Colts Orange Refractor #150 PSA 10$35.00
2017 Panini Gold Standard Andrew Luck #40 Golden Jumbo Threads 1/1 PSA 10 GEM MT$1,299.00
Topps 2012 Five Star Andrew Luck Colts Rookie Patch Auto BAS 8.5 #170 /25$250.00
Panini Absolute 2018 Iconic Ink Andrew Luck Ty Hilton dual auto /60$175.00
Reggie Wayne
Marvin Harrison
MARVIN HARRISON Rookie Auto 1996 SP Authentic Red Foil "HOF 16" Inscribed RC$399.99
1997 Pinnacle Certified 109 Marvin Harrison Mirror Gold PSA 8 Colts Low Pop READ$184.50
2004 Upper Deck SPx #42 MARVIN HARRISON 1/25 1st on Print 🔥🔥🔥$39.99
Marvin Harrison Fleer Metal Rookie Card Indianapolis Colts RC HOF$28.49
Johnny Unitas
More Colts cards on eBay
Peyton Manning - you choose! Inserts, Parallels, Game-Used, RCs! Colts NrMt$36.95
Upper Deck 2007 Artifacts Dual Artifacts Manning Harrison Colts MEM DA-MH /99$60.00
2022 Panini Legacy Alec Pierce Premium Penmanship Silver #197 RC Auto Colts$20.00
1998 Score Peyton Manning 1/1 Rookie Auto BGS 8.5 Colts RC Autograph 1 of 1$2,699.99
1998 Flair Showcase Peyton Manning #3 Indianapolis Colts RC$20.00
Panini 2025 Donruss Optic Sunday Kings Jonathan Taylor #16 Indianapolis Colts$80.00
2010 Topps Finest - Peyton Manning #10 Gold Refractor /50 Colts$1,099.00
2026 Topps Chrome National Jonathan Taylor Colts National Refractor /26$59.99
2026 Bowman Chrome Jonathan Taylor Orange Shimmer /25 Indianapolis Colts$25.00
Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts #86 Orange /25 Football Card sandglitter$25.00
2026 Topps Flagship Super Bowl Champion Signatures Reggie Wayne, Colts auto$65.00
2025 Topps Resurgence Tyler Warren RC Auto Blue Surge /99 Colts #140$80.00