NFL teams · 8 players
Indianapolis Colts Cards for Sale
The Colts cards fans hunt for, from Jonathan Taylor, Anthony Richardson, Peyton Manning, Andrew Luck and more. Each player’s cards for sale on eBay right now, today’s stars first, then the legends.
Updated Nov 15, 2026
Jonathan Taylor 2020 Panini National Treasures Gold · Rookie Patch AutographsLast seen $1,100.00
Jonathan Taylor 2020 Panini PrizmLast seen $280.00
Jonathan Taylor 2020 Panini Contenders Rookie Ticket AutographsLast seen $249.99
Jonathan Taylor 2020 Panini National Treasures Rookie Patch AutographsLast seen $140.00
Andrew Luck
2012 Panini Black Friday Pink Patch Auto Autograph #AL Andrew Luck Breast CancerLast seen $49.00
2012 Panini Prizm Andrew Luck #203 Autographs /250 (AU RC) Beckett 10 Auto 10Last seen $665.00
2017 Panini Gold Standard Andrew Luck #40 Golden Jumbo Threads 1/1 PSA 10 GEM MTLast seen $999.00
2012 Panini National Andrew Luck Holofoil RC /99 PSA 10 POP 1 Colts RookieLast seen $399.00
Reggie Wayne
2008 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia Reggie Wayne Absolute Patches /5 Colts! (GU)Last seen $199.99
2001 Bowman Chrome - Rookie Refractor Reggie Wayne #189 /1999 (RC)Last seen $45.00
Panini 2026 Donruss Football Autograph /99 #169 Reggie Wayne Colts autoLast seen $20.00
Panini 2025 Donruss Elite Etched in Time Reggie Wayne Auto /25 ETS-RWELast seen $30.00
Marvin Harrison
MINT #/25 AUTO GAME USED PATCH Marvin Harrison 2004 Playoff Absolute MemorabiliaLast seen $165.00
SkyBox Preemptive Strike Star Rubies /100 Marvin Harrison Colts #7Last seen $500.00
2000 Fleer Tradition - Autographics Marvin Harrison (AU)Last seen $95.00
1998 UD3 #216 Marvin Harrison Die-Cut /100 PSA 9 Mint Pop 1 Colts HOFLast seen $165.52
Johnny Unitas
1964 Philadelphia Gum Johnny Unitas # 12 VG-EX No CreasesLast seen $20.00
Donruss Classics 2001 Johnny Unitas Auto Significant SP Signatures Colts #172Last seen $299.00
2000 Fleer Greats Of The Game Gold Border Johnny Unitas Auto AutographLast seen $469.99
Johnny Unitas PSA 6/10 Auto 2001 Fleer Showcase Game Used Jersey Auto 22/25Last seen $600.00
More Colts cards on eBay
Peyton Manning RAINBOW HOLO FOIL REFRACTOR Variation Colts HOFLast seen $27.87
Panini 2025 Donruss Optic Jonathan Taylor Sunday Kings Insert #16 ColtsLast seen $70.00
2010 Topps Chrome Peyton Manning Orange Refractor #C50 Indianapolis Colts HOFLast seen $32.95
2024 Panini Select Jonathan Taylor #271 Club Dragon Scale Prizm 62/81 ColtsLast seen $49.97
2024 Panini Rookies & Stars Laiatu Latu Colts Draft Class #DC-LAU RC 7/10Last seen $125.00
2026 Topps Jonathan Taylor Indianapolis Colts #86 Parallel Serial Numbered 20/50Last seen $50.00
2026 Topps Bowman Football Tyler Warren Colts Gold Reptilian Refractor /50 NMLast seen $20.00
2010 Topps Chrome Joseph Addai #C154 Gold Refractor #ed 21/50 Colts RB SSPLast seen $20.00
2021 Panini Prizm Peyton Manning Blue Shimmer /25 Color Match PSA ColtsLast seen $108.88
Indianapolis Colts - SinglesLast seen $20.00
MARSHALL FAULK 1996 Select #2 PSA 10 Gem Mint Rams Colts Pop4 HOFLast seen $49.95
1999 Upper Deck MVP Peyton Manning Super Script #/25 Colts PSA 9Last seen $1,185.99











