NFL Football cards · Most popular
Tyler Warren Rookie Card Value & Most Valuable Cards
As of October 14, 2026, the most popular Tyler Warren card is the 2025 Panini Mosaic Cookies · Rookies, listed from $174.99 on eBay.
Updated
The ranking
- 2025 Panini Mosaic
Cookies · Rookies
His #354 Mosaic rookie in the short-printed Cookies version.
from $174.99 - 2025 Panini Donruss Optic
Rocket · Rated Rookie
His #234 Rated Rookie from Donruss Optic in the Rocket Prizm colour.
from $9 - 2025 Panini Mosaic
Silver · Rookie Variation
His #281 Mosaic rookie variation in Silver.
from $25
Fun fact
In 2025, Warren set a Colts record for receiving yards by a rookie tight end (817) and was named to the Pro Bowl as an alternate, making him the 18th rookie tight end in NFL history to earn Pro Bowl honors.
- 2025 Panini Donruss Optic
Blue Scope · Rated Rookie
His #234 Optic Rated Rookie in the Blue Scope Prizm colour.
from $1.25 - 2025 Panini Select
Pink Shock · Club Level
His #233 Select Club Level rookie in the Pink Shock Prizm colour.
from $1 - 2025 Panini Donruss Optic
Rated Rookie
The standard #234 Rated Rookie from Donruss Optic, his most tracked rookie card.
from $30
The cards that anchor a Tyler Warren collection: his 2025 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie (#234) and its Prizm colours, Mosaic and Select rookies, plus the lower-priced Score and Absolute cards. Ranked by collector demand; prices update daily.
- 2025 Panini Score
Rookies
His #21 Score rookie card, an inexpensive way to own his first season.
from $0.99 - #102025 Panini Select
Club Level
His standard #233 Select Club Level rookie card.
Didn’t see the one you want? Browse 57 Tyler Warren cards for sale, $1 to $399
More Indianapolis Colts cards for sale
Hot auctions
Auctions with bids for Tyler Warren, as of Oct 14, 2026. Bids and prices change fast.
Looking for one of these? Join our card-hunting beta →
More NFL rookie cards
Frequently asked
- What is Tyler Warren's rookie card?
- His rookie cards are from 2025. The most tracked is the 2025 Donruss Optic Rated Rookie #234, plus his Mosaic and Select rookies.
- What's the cheapest Tyler Warren card to start with?
- The Score and standard Optic cards are widely available and cost only a few dollars.
- What is Tyler Warren's most valuable card?
- Short-printed Mosaic rookies such as the Cookies version have listed in the hundreds of dollars.
- Are Tyler Warren cards a good investment?
- Sports cards are collectibles, not guaranteed investments. Values move with on-field performance and hobby demand and can fall as fast as they rise. This page is for research and enjoyment, not financial advice.
- What's a fun fact about Tyler Warren?
- In 2025, Warren set a Colts record for receiving yards by a rookie tight end (817) and was named to the Pro Bowl as an alternate, making him the 18th rookie tight end in NFL history to earn Pro Bowl honors.
- What's the most expensive Tyler Warren card for sale?
- As of October 14, 2026, the most expensive Tyler Warren card on our list that's for sale is the 2025 Panini Mosaic Cookies · Rookies (#1), listed from $174.99 on eBay. If you'd rather buy one, the best Tyler Warren card under $100 is the 2025 Panini Mosaic Silver · Rookie Variation (#3), listed from $25 on eBay. Prices update daily.
- What's the best Tyler Warren card under $100?
- As of October 14, 2026, it's the 2025 Panini Mosaic Silver · Rookie Variation — #3 on our list of the 10 most popular Tyler Warren cards — listed from $25 on eBay. Prices update daily.
- What's the best Tyler Warren card under $500?
- As of October 14, 2026, it's the 2025 Panini Mosaic Cookies · Rookies — #1 on our list of the 10 most popular Tyler Warren cards — listed from $174.99 on eBay. Prices update daily.
Where this comes from
How we rank these cards
We rank by popularity — how coveted a card is — not by price alone. A card rises on its iconic standing (flagship rookies, on-card autographs, and marquee inserts), its scarcity (low serial numbers and true one-of-ones), and collector demand, with market value as a strong signal. The most expensive card isn't always the most popular.
Every list is checked against several sources before it goes live. The facts — how rare a card is, what it sells for, which versions exist — come only from card checklists, price trackers, and real sold listings.
What the community is chasing shapes how we order the list, but it never counts as a fact on its own. It tells us about demand, not whether a card truly belongs at the top.
We only call a card's rarity confirmed when the maker officially publishes the number. Otherwise we label it an estimate — and we never make a number up.
Each card photo comes from the eBay listing its button points to, so you're always seeing a real card that's actually for sale — credited to that listing, never taken from the card maker.
Was this list helpful?